A recent appellate court ruling highlighted the fact that requisite consideration of fair use, when it concerns the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, might differ slightly than it traditionally did.
The U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals recently increased the burden on copyright holders attempting to prove infringement following its ruling in favor of Stephanie Lenz against Universal Music. The largest of the record labels attempted to argue that fair use is merely an affirmative defense, but Circuit Judge Richard Tallman stated in his opinion that regarding the Digital Millennium Copyright Act fair use is “uniquely situated” and should be treated differently than other traditional affirmative defenses, the Hollywood Reporter explained.
“We conclude that because 17 U.S.C. § 107 created a type of non-infringing use, fair use is ‘authorized by the law’ and a copyright holder must consider the existence of fair use before sending a takedown notification under § 512(c),” Tallman’s opinion read, according to the news outlet.
It is essential to always consider fair use in good faith
In 2007 Lenz posted a 29-second video of her toddler dancing to Prince’s “Let’s Go Crazy” to YouTube. Universal sent the video hosting website a takedown notice alleging that the clip violated publishing rights on the Prince song, and as such was a breach of the record giant’s rights. This allegation was quickly disputed by groups such as the Electronic Frontier Foundation, an organization which eventually represented Lenz in the case against her.
The EFF noted that the Digital Millennium Copyright Act requires copyright holders to at least consider the concept of fair use before issuing a takedown notice. Tallman even noted that, under § 512(f), if a copyright holder neglects to consider fair use there is a liability for damages. Copyright holders must determine that infringing material does not constitute fair use in good faith before proceeding with a takedown notice in order to remain protected from any damages that may result from unwarranted allegations of infringement.
“Today’s ruling sends a strong message that copyright law does not authorize thoughtless censorship of lawful speech,” Corynne McSherry, EFF legal director, said in a press release. “We’re pleased that the court recognized that ignoring fair use rights makes content holders liable for damages.”
The bright side for copyright holders
Still, the ruling wasn’t all bad for copyright holders, the Hollywood Reporter noted. The appeals court also considered what kind of mind frame is required to determine what constitutes fair use. On this, the court decided that if a copyright holder does in fact put the requisite consideration into whether the infringing material falls under the fair use category or not, and, in good faith, determines that it does not, the court is in no position to rule against the plaintiff.
Though the long-lasting dispute ended up in Lenz’s favor this time, it could move up to the Supreme Court since it represents more than just a disagreement over the right to post a video using copyrighted music – the case is, in fact, being used to shape copyright law as we know it.
You Just Received a Federal Grand Jury Subpoena in New Jersey: Now What?
Receiving a federal grand jury subpoena is not something most businesses or individuals anticipate. While it can be concerning, a federal grand jury subpoena does not necessarily mean that you are being accused of wrongdoing. It does, however, mean that a federal criminal investigation is underway and that federal prosecutors believe you may possess information […]
Why Every Business Should Conduct an Annual Insurance Coverage Review
Most New Jersey business owners purchase insurance policies, file them away, and assume they are protected if a claim arises. Without a regular insurance coverage review, many companies discover gaps only after a lawsuit, cyberattack, property loss, or other significant event occurs. An annual insurance coverage review can help businesses identify potential risks, ensure their […]
Demand Letters & Cease and Desist Letters: When to Send One (and When Not To)
Businesses and individuals often encounter situations where another party breaches a contract, fails to pay a debt, or continues harmful conduct. In many such disputes, a precisely drafted demand letter or cease-and-desist letter serves as a powerful legal tool. It can frequently resolve the dispute and avoid litigation. While demand or cease-and-desist letters can resolve […]
Key provisions in your contracts, including those relating to indemnification, insurance, and defense, are essential to contract risk management. While sometimes considered “boilerplate,” these provisions play a pivotal role when determining which party is responsible for certain costs and liabilities. They must always be negotiated and drafted carefully. Indemnification Clauses Businesses should never overlook the […]
Portability of estate and gift tax enables a surviving spouse to inherit any unused portion of their deceased spouse’s federal estate and gift tax exemption. So, if one spouse doesn’t utilize their full exemption, the surviving spouse can effectively double their exemption amount with regard to estate tax liability. For married couples, portability offers a […]
Pet Trusts in New Jersey and New York: A Practical Estate Planning Tool
For many of us, pets are more than companions—they are members of the family. Yet they are often overlooked or inadequately provided for when it comes to estate planning. A pet trust offers a legally enforceable way to ensure that your animal continues to receive proper care if you become incapacitated or pass away. As […]
No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.
Sign up to get the latest from our attorneys!
Explore What Matters Most to You.
Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.
Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.
Let`s get in touch!
Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!
