What if the iconic end to the film “Fight Club” featured the lyrics to The Pixies’ “Where is my Mind?” scrolling across the bottom of the screen? What if the words to Redbone’s “Come and Get Your Love” distracted from Chris Pratt’s beloved dance scene at the start of “Guardians of the Galaxy?”
While such subtitling may alter the viewing experience for some movies, one lawsuit claims that in the future, song lyrics should be captioned or at the very least, films should include a warning to deaf consumers explaining the lack of captioning. Numerous advocates for improved accessibility for the deaf and hard-of-hearing agree.
Will future DVD, theater and streaming releases include song lyric subtitles?
The law requires that individuals with hearing disabilities are given equal access to entertainment, and the litigation contends that movies that don’t include captioning for song lyrics violate this regulation. The lawsuit claims that movie studios’ failure to provide subtitles for song lyrics takes away from deaf and hard-of-hearing viewers’ experiences. Could this lawsuit change the way that studios approach captioning in the future? Not if the studios’ arguments against such requirements succeed.
Studios’ arguments against song lyric subtitles
The defendants outlined three reasons why the lawsuit filed by members of the Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing should fail. Sony, Warner Bros., Universal, Disney, Paramount and Buena Vista Home Entertainment filed dismissal motions explaining their arguments.
For example, they state that although studios are required to offer captioning, no reasonable consumer would understand that to apply to song lyrics in addition to conversation. While the lawsuit alleges false advertising, the studios argue that the reasonable viewer’s understanding of captioning requirements absolves them of misrepresentation. This argument addresses the allegations that the studios are guilty of false advertising, but does not speak to claims that the lack of lyric captioning is a breach of civil rights legislation.
The Telecommunications Act of 1996 & the 21st Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act of 2010
The Telecommunications Act of 1996 and the 21st Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act of 2010 each offer studios guidelines concerning captioning requirements. The former legislation mandated that “manufacturers of telecommunications equipment and providers of telecommunications services” provide equal access to people with disabilities. The latter, meanwhile, explains closed captioning requirements for video that is distributed via the Internet and programming devices. The Federal Communications Commissions’ outline of the regulation repeatedly mentions television, but does not address movies.
This is what the studios’ argument points to – that their film productions are not regulated in the same way as television is. The defendants’ dismissal motions note that closed captioning rules apply to broadcast television, but not to DVDs, streaming or theaters. The defendants claim that they are allowed to caption music included in movies as they see fit, and are not required to include subtitles for the lyrics of every song used in films.
In their dismissal motions, the studios also reference a 2006 settlement on DVD closed captioning that seems to acknowledge that all song lyrics do not require closed captioning. This prior ruling, combined with their arguments against false advertising and civil rights violations are what the studios are banking on to push dismissal of the lawsuit against them.
Music is important to movies, and the lyrics sometimes are part of the reason why. Other times they are just a component of the song. Either way, it seems some civil rights groups feel that lyrics should always be subtitled in future film releases. Whether the court decides the studios’ have a legitimate argument against such a notion remains to be seen.
You Just Received a Federal Grand Jury Subpoena in New Jersey: Now What?
Receiving a federal grand jury subpoena is not something most businesses or individuals anticipate. While it can be concerning, a federal grand jury subpoena does not necessarily mean that you are being accused of wrongdoing. It does, however, mean that a federal criminal investigation is underway and that federal prosecutors believe you may possess information […]
Why Every Business Should Conduct an Annual Insurance Coverage Review
Most New Jersey business owners purchase insurance policies, file them away, and assume they are protected if a claim arises. Without a regular insurance coverage review, many companies discover gaps only after a lawsuit, cyberattack, property loss, or other significant event occurs. An annual insurance coverage review can help businesses identify potential risks, ensure their […]
Demand Letters & Cease and Desist Letters: When to Send One (and When Not To)
Businesses and individuals often encounter situations where another party breaches a contract, fails to pay a debt, or continues harmful conduct. In many such disputes, a precisely drafted demand letter or cease-and-desist letter serves as a powerful legal tool. It can frequently resolve the dispute and avoid litigation. While demand or cease-and-desist letters can resolve […]
Key provisions in your contracts, including those relating to indemnification, insurance, and defense, are essential to contract risk management. While sometimes considered “boilerplate,” these provisions play a pivotal role when determining which party is responsible for certain costs and liabilities. They must always be negotiated and drafted carefully. Indemnification Clauses Businesses should never overlook the […]
Portability of estate and gift tax enables a surviving spouse to inherit any unused portion of their deceased spouse’s federal estate and gift tax exemption. So, if one spouse doesn’t utilize their full exemption, the surviving spouse can effectively double their exemption amount with regard to estate tax liability. For married couples, portability offers a […]
Pet Trusts in New Jersey and New York: A Practical Estate Planning Tool
For many of us, pets are more than companions—they are members of the family. Yet they are often overlooked or inadequately provided for when it comes to estate planning. A pet trust offers a legally enforceable way to ensure that your animal continues to receive proper care if you become incapacitated or pass away. As […]
No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.
Sign up to get the latest from our attorneys!
Explore What Matters Most to You.
Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.
Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.
Let`s get in touch!
Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!
